Our orders are delivered strictly on time without delay 
Ch. 11 Explain the underlying sources of police discretion.
Sample Answer
Understanding the Underlying Sources of Police Discretion
Introduction
Police discretion refers to the power and authority that police officers possess to make decisions in various situations. It allows officers to exercise judgment and choose between different courses of action based on their professional judgment and the circumstances they encounter. In this essay, we will explain the underlying sources of police discretion, considering the who, what, where, when, why, and how of this important aspect of law enforcement.
Who
The individuals with the authority to exercise police discretion are police officers themselves. They are trained professionals responsible for maintaining public order, preventing crime, and enforcing the law. Police officers are granted the legal authority and discretion to make decisions based on their training, experience, and knowledge of the law.
What
The sources of police discretion can be categorized into three main areas:
Legal Factors: Police officers exercise discretion based on legal factors such as the severity of the offense, evidence of criminal activity, applicable laws, and the rights of individuals involved. Legal factors guide officers in determining how to handle a situation within the boundaries of the law.
Departmental Policies and Guidelines: Police departments often provide policies and guidelines that influence officer decision-making. These policies can range from general guidance on how to handle specific situations to more specific directives on issues such as use of force or pursuits. Departmental policies help shape officers’ discretionary choices by providing standards and expectations.
Individual Officer Factors: Individual officers bring their own personal characteristics, beliefs, experiences, and biases into their decision-making process. Factors such as an officer’s training, attitudes, values, and perceptions can influence their use of discretion. These individual factors vary from officer to officer and can impact the outcomes of encounters with the public.
Where
Police discretion can be exercised in a variety of locations where law enforcement is present. This includes public spaces such as streets, parks, or businesses, as well as private residences or other locations where police officers may be called to respond to incidents.
When
Police discretion is exercised in real-time encounters with the public. Officers make decisions in the moment when they are faced with a particular situation or incident. The timing of these decisions depends on when incidents occur or when officers encounter individuals engaging in potentially criminal or suspicious behavior.
Why
Several reasons contribute to the existence of police discretion:
Flexibility: Police discretion allows officers to adapt their responses to specific circumstances rather than being bound by strict rules or protocols. It enables them to consider the unique factors of each situation and make decisions accordingly.
Efficiency: Given limited resources and time constraints, police discretion helps officers prioritize situations based on their assessment of urgency or severity. This allows them to allocate their resources effectively and efficiently.
Professional Judgment: Police officers are trusted with making decisions based on their training, experience, and knowledge of the law. Discretion allows officers to exercise their professional judgment and apply their understanding of the situation to determine an appropriate course of action.
Community Policing Principles: Community policing emphasizes building trust and positive relationships between police and the community. Discretion allows officers to consider community needs and concerns when making decisions, fostering cooperation and collaboration.
How
The exercise of police discretion involves a dynamic process that varies depending on the situation at hand. Officers assess the facts and circumstances of each incident, consider relevant legal factors and departmental policies, and apply their professional judgment to determine the most appropriate response.
Officers may engage in a variety of actions such as issuing a warning or citation, making an arrest, mediating disputes, providing guidance or referrals to social services, or using alternative resolution methods. The specific actions taken by officers will depend on the nature of the incident, applicable laws, departmental policies, and individual officer judgment.
Conclusion
In conclusion, police discretion is an integral part of law enforcement that allows police officers to make decisions based on their professional judgment and the circumstances they encounter. The sources of police discretion include legal factors, departmental policies, and individual officer characteristics. This discretionary power enables flexibility, promotes efficiency, allows for professional judgment, and aligns with community policing principles. By understanding who exercises discretion, what factors influence it, where it is exercised, when it occurs, why it exists, and how it is applied, we gain insight into this important aspect of law enforcement decision-making.
