In their article “Understanding Racial/ethnic Disparities in Health: Sociological Contributions,” Williams and Sternthal challenge the notion that biological factors alone can account for health inequalities among different racial and ethnic groups. They argue that sociological research provides strong evidence that social determinants play a significant role in shaping racial/ethnic health disparities.
One way Williams and Sternthal refute the idea of biological bases for health inequalities is by highlighting the consistent patterns of disparities across racial and ethnic groups that cannot be explained solely by genetics or biology. They argue that if biological factors were the sole drivers of health disparities, we would not see such persistent and consistent differences in health outcomes between racial and ethnic groups over time.
Additionally, Williams and Sternthal discuss the impact of social determinants of health, such as socioeconomic status, discrimination, and neighborhood characteristics. They emphasize that these social factors contribute to the unequal distribution of resources, opportunities, and exposures that ultimately shape health outcomes. Sociological research has consistently shown that marginalized racial and ethnic groups face higher levels of poverty, limited access to quality healthcare, greater exposure to environmental hazards, and higher levels of discrimination – all of which contribute to health disparities.
Furthermore, Williams and Sternthal argue that sociological research has demonstrated the importance of examining the intersectionality of race/ethnicity with other social categories like gender, class, and immigration status. They explain how multiple systems of oppression intersect to shape health outcomes, emphasizing that it is the social context in which individuals live that influences their health, rather than inherent biological differences.
By highlighting these sociological contributions, Williams and Sternthal provide evidence that social determinants, rather than biological factors alone, are critical in understanding and addressing racial/ethnic health disparities. They emphasize the need for interventions and policies that target the social determinants of health to reduce these disparities.