Our orders are delivered strictly on time without delay 
Discuss the problems with the first form of government in the United States and why the Articles of Confederation had to be amended (or ultimately replaced).
Sample Answer
Full Answer Section
Title: The Problems with the Articles of Confederation: The Need for Amendment and Replacement
Introduction
After gaining independence from Britain, the United States initially operated under the Articles of Confederation, a governing document that established a weak central government. However, several problems emerged, leading to the need for amendment or replacement. This essay examines the issues with the first form of government in the United States and why the Articles of Confederation required revision.
I. Weak Central Government
The Articles of Confederation created a decentralized system, granting significant power to the individual states and a weak central government. This structure resulted in several problems.
Inadequate National Defense
Lack of a standing army: The central government did not have the authority to raise and maintain a standing army, relying on state militias for defense. This weakened the nation’s ability to protect itself and respond to potential threats effectively.
Inconsistent contributions: States were responsible for providing troops and funding for common defense, but many failed to meet their obligations, leading to an unreliable and underfunded military.
Limited Economic Power
Inability to levy taxes: The central government could not levy taxes directly on individuals, relying on the voluntary contributions of the states. This resulted in a lack of funds to support national programs and services.
Trade barriers: Each state had the authority to regulate commerce, leading to trade disputes and barriers between states. This hindered economic growth and the establishment of a unified national market.
II. Weak Central Authority
The Articles of Confederation established a weak central authority that lacked the necessary powers to govern effectively.
Lack of Executive Branch
Absence of a national executive: The Articles of Confederation did not create an executive branch to enforce laws and execute policies. This resulted in a lack of leadership, coordination, and accountability at the national level.
Inefficient Decision-Making
Unanimous consent requirement: Important decisions, including amendments to the Articles, required unanimous approval from all the states. This made it challenging to pass legislation and address national issues promptly.
Weak central judiciary: The central government had limited authority over the judiciary, resulting in inconsistent interpretation and enforcement of laws across states.
III. Ineffective Foreign Relations
The Articles of Confederation hindered the United States’ ability to conduct effective foreign relations.
International Reputation
Lack of credibility: The weak central government and its inability to honor national debts or negotiate treaties effectively diminished the United States’ credibility and reputation in the eyes of foreign nations.
Trade challenges: The lack of a unified national trade policy made it difficult to negotiate favorable trade agreements and protect American economic interests abroad.
IV. The Need for Amendment or Replacement
The problems encountered under the Articles of Confederation led to the realization that a stronger form of government was necessary for the United States to operate effectively as a nation.
Shays’ Rebellion
Uprising in Massachusetts: Shays’ Rebellion, an armed uprising of farmers in Massachusetts due to economic hardships, exposed the weaknesses of the central government and its inability to maintain law and order.
Demonstrated need for a stronger government: The rebellion demonstrated the need for a central authority with the power to address domestic unrest and maintain stability.
Constitutional Convention and Ratification
The Constitutional Convention: In 1787, delegates gathered to revise the Articles of Confederation but ultimately decided to draft a new governing document, the United States Constitution.
Ratification: The Constitution was subsequently ratified by the states, establishing a stronger central government that addressed the shortcomings of the Articles of Confederation.
Conclusion
The Articles of Confederation suffered from significant problems that necessitated amendment or replacement. The weak central government, limited economic power, lack of executive authority, inefficient decision-making, ineffective foreign relations, and the challenges highlighted by Shays’ Rebellion all contributed to the realization that a stronger form of government was required. This led to the drafting and ratification of the United States Constitution, which established a more effective and balanced system of governance, addressing the shortcomings of the Articles of Confederation and providing a solid foundation for the nation’s future.
