Our orders are delivered strictly on time without delay 
In discussing nationalism, historians are divided over whether or not people had any sort of national identity prior to the nineteenth century—many say that it had its roots in much earlier periods. Do you agree? What other kinds of identity competed with national identity in two periods (defined above) of European history?
Sample Answer
The Development of National Identity in European History
Introduction
The concept of national identity and its origins in European history has been a topic of debate among historians. While some argue that national identity emerged primarily in the 19th century, others assert that its roots can be traced back to earlier periods. This essay aims to explore the development of national identity in European history and identify other types of identity that competed with national identity in two distinct time periods.
Pre-Nineteenth Century: Medieval and Early Modern Periods
During the medieval and early modern periods, European societies were characterized by a range of identities that coexisted alongside nascent national sentiments. These competing identities included:
Regional Identities: People often identified strongly with their local regions, such as Catalonia, Bavaria, or Normandy. These regional identities were shaped by distinct cultural, linguistic, and historical factors, fostering a sense of belonging and loyalty to one’s region.
Religious Identities: Religion played a central role in shaping individual and collective identities. Catholicism, Protestantism, and other religious affiliations were powerful sources of identity that transcended national boundaries, resulting in conflicts like the Reformation and Counter-Reformation.
Dynastic Loyalties: Loyalty to ruling dynasties, such as the Habsburgs or the Bourbons, was another significant form of identity. People often identified themselves with their ruling family rather than a broader national community.
Guild and Urban Identities: In the growing urban centers of Europe, guilds and urban communities developed distinct identities. People identified themselves based on their profession or trade affiliation, emphasizing their urban citizenship rather than a national identity.
Nineteenth Century: Rise of Nationalism
The 19th century witnessed a surge in nationalist movements across Europe. While national identity had its roots in earlier periods, it became more prominent during this era. Competing identities during this time included:
Ethnic Identities: As nationalism gained momentum, ethnic identities became significant factors in shaping national identities. People with shared cultural, linguistic, or historical backgrounds often came together to form nations based on these ethnic ties.
Political Ideologies: Political ideologies like liberalism, socialism, and conservatism also competed with national identity during the 19th century. These ideologies offered alternative frameworks through which individuals could identify themselves and mobilize for political change.
Imperial Identities: The expansion of European empires brought about imperial identities that sometimes overshadowed national identities. Citizens of imperial powers often identified themselves as subjects of the empire rather than as members of a specific nation.
Class Identities: Class divisions persisted during this period, with people identifying themselves primarily based on their social class. The working class, bourgeoisie, and aristocracy had distinct identities that occasionally superseded national identity.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the development of national identity in European history is a complex and evolving process. While historians debate whether national identity emerged primarily in the 19th century or had earlier roots, it is clear that other identities competed with national identity throughout different periods. In medieval and early modern times, regional, religious, dynastic, and urban identities were prominent. In the 19th century, ethnic, political, imperial, and class identities vied for prominence alongside nascent nationalism. Understanding these competing sources of identity provides valuable insight into the diverse factors that have shaped European history and the complexities of individual and collective allegiances throughout time.
