Criminal Justice Ethics

 

Scenario:

Sue Yoo is a new attorney fresh out of law school. Yoo has accepted a position with the Grantham County District Attorney’s office as an assistant prosecuting attorney.

The first day on the job, Chris P. Bacon, who is also an assistant district attorney introduces himself to Yoo and says, “I am your mentor for the first 90-days to help you get acclimated to your new job.” Bacon shows Yoo to her office.

As Yoo admires her, new oak desk and bookcase filled with brand-new law books,

Bacon hands Yoo the large stack of files he had been carrying.

Bacon tells Yoo, “These are your files to prosecute.” Bacon turns away from Yoo and starts to walk toward the door, but instead of leaving, he shuts the door quietly. Bacon then turns around and walks back to Yoo’s desk and states, “I do not know what you learned in law school, but in the real world, the attorneys around here work under time and money constraints.” Bacon continues to explain how the attorneys handle the cases in their office and the point system.

Yoo looked confused, and asked Bacon, “What are you trying to tell me?”

Bacon said, “Yoo, you look like a smart girl, so let me lay it out for you, get through these cases quickly, offer the defendants’ plea deals, and for each case that ends with a conviction, you will get five points.” At the end of the month, the assistant district attorney with the most points receives an extra day of vacation, off the books, of course.” Bacon pauses, looks Yoo in the eyes, and states, “If you have a problem with this, there is the door, and this conversation never happened, but if not, welcome to the team.”

“Always remember that law is considered the basement of morality; even if you never break a law that does not automatically make you a moral person” (Pollock, 2019, p. 75).

References

Pollock, J. M. (2019). Ethical dilemmas and decisions in criminal justice (10th ed.). Boston, MA: Cengage Learning.

Assignment:

In 2 to 3 paragraphs, with a minimum of 250 words, apply two out of the seven – Bandura’s mechanisms listed in chapter 4 (workgroup and organizational influences) to the above scenario. Evaluate how the ethical climate of an organization precipitates how employees behave and believe what acceptable ethical behavior is in the workplace.

Criminal Justice Ethics

 

 

Part I
Review the professional ethical and code of conduct standards for two of the professional associations
suggested below. Next, respond to the assignment questions.
Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences (Links to an external site.)
American Psychological Association (Links to an external site.)
American Educational Research Association (Links to an external site.)
American Medical Association (Links to an external site.)
World Medical Association (Links to an external site.)
Office for the Protection of Research Subjects (Links to an external site.)
Part I Questions:
Based on your review of two of the above association ethical standards, what are two standards that appear to
be represented across both professions? Why do you believe that these standards are so universal?
What ethical dilemmas do you believe may still be present, despite the adoption of such comprehensive
professional standards? Explain why these dilemmas are still present.
Part II
To begin Part II of this assignment, you will be assigned a research study for further examination. Your
assignment will be based on last name. Please research the study assigned and respond to the questions
below.
Research Study:
Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment (THIS IS WHAT MY RESEARCH STUDY WILL BE OVER)
Part II Questions:
Identify the primary ethical dilemmas faced by the researchers in your assigned research study. Did the
researchers handle the dilemmas in an ethical and professional manner? Explain your response.
Do the current ethical standards for working with human subjects address these dilemmas? Explain your
response.
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeContent
Lists two universal ethical standards; explains why the standards are universal; identifies ethical dilemmas that
currently exist and explains why they exist; identifies the assigned research study and the ethical dilemmas
present; discusses whether or not the researchers were professional in how they handled the ethical issues;
and explains how current standards address similar issues today