Portrayal of Mental Health in Television Shows: A Comparative Analysis of “13 Reasons Why” and “BoJack Horseman”

Title: Portrayal of Mental Health in Television Shows: A Comparative Analysis of “13 Reasons Why” and “BoJack Horseman”

Introduction

Television shows have immense influence on our perception of various societal issues, including mental health. This essay aims to critically analyze the portrayal of mental health in two popular television shows: “13 Reasons Why” and “BoJack Horseman.” By examining the depiction of mental health in these shows, we can gain insights into how they address important topics such as suicide, depression, and addiction, and evaluate their effectiveness in raising awareness and reducing stigma.

“13 Reasons Why”

“13 Reasons Why” is a controversial series that gained significant attention due to its portrayal of suicide. The show follows the aftermath of a teenager’s suicide and explores the reasons leading up to her decision through a series of cassette tapes she leaves behind. While the show aimed to raise awareness about the impact of bullying and other issues faced by teenagers, it received criticism for its graphic depiction of self-harm and suicide, potentially glamorizing or romanticizing such actions.

The show’s portrayal of mental health raises concerns regarding its potential influence on vulnerable viewers. Research indicates that media representation of suicide can have a contagion effect, leading to an increase in suicidal thoughts and behaviors. The lack of adequate discussion around mental health support and resources in the show also contributes to its problematic portrayal.

“BoJack Horseman”

In contrast, “BoJack Horseman” is an animated series that tackles mental health issues through a more nuanced approach. The show revolves around the life of a washed-up sitcom star struggling with depression, addiction, and existential crises. The series cleverly combines humor with deep introspection, providing a realistic portrayal of mental health struggles and highlighting the importance of seeking help.

“BoJack Horseman” addresses complex issues such as depression and addiction with sensitivity and depth. It delves into the underlying causes of these conditions and explores the impact they have on individuals’ relationships and personal growth. The show also emphasizes the significance of therapy and self-reflection as vital components in the journey towards healing.

Comparative Analysis

When comparing the two shows, it becomes evident that “BoJack Horseman” offers a more responsible and effective portrayal of mental health than “13 Reasons Why.” While both shows tackle important topics, “BoJack Horseman” stands out for its ability to balance realism with empathy and provide viewers with a more comprehensive understanding of mental health struggles.

“13 Reasons Why” may have sparked conversations about teenage mental health, but its explicit depiction of suicide can be harmful to vulnerable individuals. On the other hand, “BoJack Horseman” takes a more nuanced approach, exploring mental health issues in a way that encourages empathy, understanding, and destigmatization.

Conclusion

Television shows play a crucial role in shaping our perceptions of various societal issues, including mental health. Through a comparative analysis of “13 Reasons Why” and “BoJack Horseman,” we can see the importance of responsible media representation when addressing sensitive topics like suicide, depression, and addiction. While “13 Reasons Why” received criticism for its problematic portrayal, “BoJack Horseman” demonstrated how a show can effectively raise awareness and promote understanding without glamorizing or promoting harmful behaviors. It is essential for media creators to approach mental health depictions with caution and prioritize responsible storytelling to reduce stigma, educate viewers, and encourage positive conversations about mental well-being.