Exploring Arranged Marriages: Perspectives and Comparisons

 

Title: Exploring Arranged Marriages: Perspectives and Comparisons

Thoughts on the belief system regarding arranged marriages:
The belief system regarding arranged marriages portrayed in the movie “Arranged” was complex. It showcased the cultural traditions and expectations surrounding arranged marriages, highlighting the pressure faced by Rochel and Nasira to conform to their communities’ expectations. The movie provided insights into the internal struggles faced by the protagonists as they balanced their personal desires with societal and familial obligations.

Cultural similarities and differences between families in the movie and other U.S. families:
a. Differences:
i. Role of parents: In the movie, Rochel and Nasira’s parents play a significant role in arranging their marriages, whereas in many U.S. families, individuals have more autonomy in choosing their partners.
ii. Importance of cultural and religious values: The families in the movie emphasize cultural and religious compatibility as a primary consideration for marriage, which may differ from the emphasis placed on individual preferences in some U.S. families.
iii. Gender roles: The movie presents traditional gender roles, where men are expected to be the primary breadwinners and women take on domestic responsibilities. This may differ from the evolving gender dynamics in many U.S. families.

b. Similarities:
i. Love and support: Like many U.S. families, the families in the movie exhibit love and support for their children, even if they have different approaches to marriage.
ii. Nurturing family bonds: Both the families in the movie and many U.S. families prioritize maintaining strong family bonds and connections.
iii. The desire for happiness: The pursuit of happiness and fulfillment for their children is a shared value between the families in the movie and many U.S. families.

Differences between forced, arranged, and traditional romantic marriages:
a. Forced marriage: In a forced marriage, one or both parties are coerced or unwillingly forced into the union without their consent or choice.
b. Arranged marriage: In an arranged marriage, families or trusted intermediaries play a significant role in selecting potential partners based on various factors such as compatibility, social standing, and shared values. However, the final decision rests with the individuals involved, who have the freedom to accept or reject the proposed arrangement.
c. Traditional romantic marriage: A traditional romantic marriage is based on mutual love, attraction, and personal choice between two individuals without external influence or intervention.

Case for arranged marriages vs. traditional romantic marriages:
The readings provide diverse perspectives on this topic, making it difficult to draw a definitive conclusion. However, some arguments can be made for both sides:
a. Arranged marriages:

Supporters argue that they promote stability, as factors like compatibility and shared values are carefully considered.
Arranged marriages may have lower divorce rates due to the emphasis on long-term commitment and family support.
b. Traditional romantic marriages:
Advocates argue that personal choice and emotional connection lead to greater satisfaction and fulfillment in relationships.
Romantic marriages prioritize individual autonomy and independence, allowing for personal growth and development.

Comparing arranged marriages to internet romances or matchmaking sites:
a. Similarities:

Both arranged marriages and internet romances/online matchmaking involve individuals seeking life partners with specific preferences or criteria.
Both approaches aim to find compatibility between individuals.
b. Differences:
Arranged marriages rely on family or trusted intermediaries for partner selection, while internet romances or matchmaking sites give individuals more autonomy in choosing their partners.
Internet romances focus primarily on individual preferences and attraction, while arranged marriages consider broader factors such as family compatibility and cultural harmony.

Role of parents in children’s marriage and their ability to know what is best for them:
Parents can play a supportive role in their children’s marriages by providing guidance, wisdom, and emotional support. However, it is crucial to recognize that each individual has unique desires, needs, and aspirations. While parents may have valuable insights, they should respect their children’s autonomy and allow them to make their own choices based on personal judgment.

Expectations of love and marriage’s impact on our vision of marriage:
Expectations of love and marriage can have both positive and negative effects. Positive expectations can inspire individuals to seek fulfilling relationships based on love, respect, and mutual support. However, unrealistic or rigid expectations can lead to disappointment, dissatisfaction, and strained relationships when reality does not align with these expectations.

Personal view on arranged marriage before watching the movie and reading the articles:
Before watching the movie and reading the articles, my view on arranged marriages was influenced by cultural stereotypes and limited understanding. I believed that arranged marriages were restrictive and lacked genuine emotional connection.

Revised view on arranged marriage:
After watching the movie and reading the articles, my view on arranged marriages has become more nuanced. I now understand that arranged marriages can vary in their dynamics and outcomes, ranging from forced to consensual arrangements based on shared values and compatibility. I recognize that cultural contexts, individual agency, and personal experiences can shape the success or challenges of arranged marriages.

The place of arranged marriage in U.S. culture:
Arranged marriages may not align with the predominant cultural norms surrounding marriage in the United States, where individual choice and romantic love are highly valued. However, as a multicultural society, there is room for diverse perspectives on relationships and marriage practices within different communities. It is essential to respect individuals’ autonomy while fostering understanding and appreciation for different cultural practices surrounding marriage.

Conclusion:
The exploration of arranged marriages through the movie “Arranged” and related readings provides valuable insights into cultural traditions, identity dynamics, and societal expectations regarding marriage practices. By understanding the complexities of different marriage types, we can foster a more inclusive perspective that respects individual autonomy while appreciating diverse cultural practices surrounding marriage.