Scenario: Ethical Problems Related to Patients and Prescription Drug Use
In this scenario, a healthcare worker, Sarah, is a nurse at a community clinic that serves a population with a high prevalence of substance abuse and addiction. One of her patients, John, has a history of opioid addiction and is currently receiving treatment for chronic pain. However, Sarah suspects that John may be misusing his prescription medication and potentially even selling it to support his addiction.
Ethical Solutions:
Care-based Ethics: Sarah can approach the situation with care-based ethics by prioritizing the well-being and best interests of the patient. She can engage in open and non-judgmental communication with John, expressing her concerns and offering support and resources for addiction treatment. Sarah can advocate for a holistic approach to his care, ensuring that his pain management needs are met while also addressing his addiction.
Assessment: This solution is based on empathy and compassion, acknowledging that addiction is a complex issue and requires a comprehensive approach. However, care-based ethics alone may not fully address the potential harm caused by John’s misuse of prescription drugs or the need for legal consequences.
Rights Ethics: Sarah can also consider rights ethics by focusing on respecting John’s autonomy and individual rights, while also recognizing the rights and safety of other patients who might be affected by his drug misuse. In this case, Sarah can inform John about the potential consequences of his actions, such as legal ramifications or harm to his health, and empower him to make informed decisions regarding his treatment.
Assessment: While respecting individual rights is important, it may be challenging to balance John’s autonomy with the potential harm caused by his actions. Rights ethics alone might not fully address the duty of healthcare workers to protect public safety and prevent harm.
Healthcare Technology and Moral Guidelines:
The healthcare technology involved in this situation is the prescription drug monitoring program (PDMP), which tracks controlled substance prescriptions filled by patients. Moral guidelines for using PDMP should consider:
Utilitarianism: Utilitarianism would focus on maximizing overall happiness or minimizing harm. In this case, using PDMP can help identify patients who are potentially misusing or diverting prescription drugs, thus preventing harm to individuals and society as a whole.
Kantian Deontology: Kantian ethics would emphasize the duty to follow moral rules and principles. In this context, using PDMP aligns with the principle of treating others as ends in themselves rather than means to an end, by promoting the well-being and safety of patients.
Ethical Egoism: Ethical egoism would prioritize self-interest and personal benefit. Using PDMP in this scenario could benefit healthcare workers by ensuring adherence to legal and ethical standards, enhancing patient safety, and potentially reducing liability.
Social Contract Ethics: Social contract ethics would focus on the mutual obligations and agreements between individuals and society. Using PDMP can be seen as fulfilling the societal expectation to protect public health and safety by identifying potential prescription drug misuse or diversion.
Social Technologies:
In this scenario, social technologies such as blogs, crowdfunding, and online encyclopedias can be used to raise awareness about substance abuse issues, provide education on safe medication practices, and offer support for individuals struggling with addiction. Moral guidelines for using these technologies could consider:
Utilitarianism: These technologies can promote overall happiness by disseminating accurate information, facilitating access to resources for addiction treatment, and reducing stigma associated with substance abuse.
Kantian Deontology: These technologies can align with the principle of respect for autonomy by providing individuals with knowledge and resources to make informed decisions about their health and seek help when needed.
Ethical Egoism: Social technologies can benefit healthcare workers by connecting them with a larger community of professionals, allowing for collaboration and sharing of best practices in addressing issues related to substance abuse.
Social Contract Ethics: Using these technologies can fulfill the societal obligation to promote public health by disseminating accurate information, raising awareness about substance abuse issues, and fostering support networks for individuals in need.
Assessment: While social technologies offer valuable opportunities for education, support, and community engagement, ethical guidelines should ensure the accuracy of information shared, respect for privacy and confidentiality, and protection against potential harm or exploitation.
Overall, addressing ethical problems related to patients and prescription drug use requires a multifaceted approach that balances care-based ethics, rights ethics, consideration of healthcare technology, and moral guidelines derived from various ethical frameworks.
Our orders are delivered strictly on time without delay 
