Advice on Potential Claims in Tort

John went to the store The security guard suspected him of stealing a toaster. John was taken to a waiting room where he was told that he was needed to give evidence. He stayed there quietly for 2 hours. Unknown to John, the guard locked the door. After not finding a toaster on him John was about to be released but on his way out an employee of the store stood with a bucket of water and told him that he has to clean him of his dirty thoughts of stealing from the store and threw the
water at him. After that hard experience John went home to relax. He sat by the window to look at cars and pedestrians passing on the highway. John was the victim of extreme racial harassment by
persons using the highway. He called the police. The police officer who came was disruptive and made John feel very uncomfortable. John asked him to leave but he told him that this is his house
now and the police officer stayed for 3 hours in John’s apartment. Advice John on any claims in tort

Guiding questions:
1) consider the following potential tortfeasors: the store employees, the highway users, the
police officer.
2) Consider whether there was trespass to land, battery, false imprisonment and nuisance.

Sample Answer

Issue

John has encountered several incidents that may give rise to potential claims in tort. These incidents involve the store employees, the highway users, and the police officer. The torts to consider are trespass to land, battery, false imprisonment, and nuisance.

Rules/Law Applicable

Trespass to Land: Trespass to land occurs when a person intentionally enters or remains on another person’s property without permission. This includes locking someone inside a room against their will.Bird v. Holbrook: In this case, it was held that if someone enters or remains on another person’s land without permission, they commit trespass.

Battery: Battery occurs when a person intentionally and unlawfully makes physical contact with another person without their consent.Letang v Cooper: In this case, it was held that battery requires intentional and direct physical contact with another person without their consent.

False Imprisonment: False imprisonment occurs when a person intentionally and unlawfully restricts another person’s freedom of movement without lawful justification.Bernstein v Skyviews and General Ltd: In this case, it was held that false imprisonment can occur when someone intentionally and unlawfully restricts another person’s freedom of movement.

Nuisance: Nuisance occurs when a person unreasonably interferes with another person’s use or enjoyment of their property.Delaney v T P Smith & Co: In this case, it was held that a nuisance can be established if a person unreasonably interferes with another person’s use or enjoyment of their property.

Application

Store Employees:The store employees may be liable for false imprisonment as they locked John in a waiting room without his consent.
They may also be liable for battery if they forcefully threw water at John without his consent.

Highway Users:The individuals on the highway who racially harassed John may be liable for nuisance as their actions unreasonably interfered with his use and enjoyment of his property (his apartment).

Police Officer:The police officer may be liable for trespass to land as he remained in John’s apartment without his consent after being asked to leave.
The police officer may also be liable for false imprisonment if he intentionally restricted John’s freedom of movement within his own apartment.

Conclusion/Advice

Based on the facts presented, John may have potential claims in tort against the store employees for false imprisonment and battery, against the highway users for nuisance, and against the police officer for trespass to land and false imprisonment. However, it is important to note that the application of these torts may vary depending on the jurisdiction and specific facts of the case.

To proceed with these claims, John should seek legal advice from a qualified attorney who can assess the specific circumstances, apply relevant case law, and guide him through the legal process. It is crucial to gather evidence such as witness statements, photographs, and any documentation related to these incidents to strengthen his case.

References to relevant cases should be made to support the advice given and provide a legal basis for the potential claims in tort.

This question has been answered.

Get Answer

Subject:
Type:
Pages/Words:
	Single spaced
	approx 275 words per page
Urgency:
Level:
Currency:
Total Cost:

No More Worries!

Paper Formatting

No Lateness!

AEW Guarantees

Sample Answer

This question has been answered.

Compute Cost of Paper

Our Services

Why Choose Us