No More Worries!


Our orders are delivered strictly on time without delay

Paper Formatting

  • Double or single-spaced
  • 1-inch margin
  • 12 Font Arial or Times New Roman
  • 300 words per page

No Lateness!

image Our orders are delivered strictly on time without delay

AEW Guarantees

image

  • Free Unlimited revisions
  • Guaranteed Privacy
  • Money Return guarantee
  • Plagiarism Free Writing

Animal Minds: Rethinking Reason in Non-Human Animals

The third part of your term paper assignment is a rough draft. At this stage you should be able to clearly articulate the position that you will defend (or develop) and be able to consider objections and responses to that position, even if not yet complete. Your bibliography will become Works Cited and will now include only what you refer to in the paper. The topic being Animal minds (Descartes versus???)

What you will need to do is:

First, focus on reason, not consciousness. No one today thinks that animals lack consciousness and no one has accepted Cartesian substance dualism for a few hundred years. You need to focus on reason, not on consciousness.

Second, find some fairly contemporary philosophical literature arguing that animas do not reason. You mention Dawkins saying that we need to look at Science but those who think animals cannot reason are not ignoring the science, rather they are tying reason to thinks like concept use and concept use to language.  Science alone won’t answer them. What is needed are arguments about the nature of reason.

Check out the SEP article on animal cognition. (here is the link https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/cognition-animal/).  It will give you a sense of the debate because you want to frame your paper in terms of that debate. I would suggest beginning with a very brief (paragraph–no more) on D and the post Cartesian legacy and then get into the contemporary debate.

Third, you can bring in the ethnology and animal cognition material from Science as support for an account of reasoning under which animals reason. You can also look to historical figures like Hume who think that animals engage in causal reasoning, The main task you have in this paper is to challenge the idea that reason is a narrow phenomenon connected to language use. Using De Waal on animal intelligence is fine as a key source, but he is not a philosopher and you will need to have an understanding of the opposing philosophical position (which you might not get from him).

Sample Answer

 

 

 

Animal Minds: Rethinking Reason in Non-Human Animals

Introduction

In the realm of philosophical inquiry, the question of whether animals possess the ability to reason has been a subject of debate for centuries. While Descartes famously argued that animals lack reason and are merely automatons driven by instinct, contemporary scholarship challenges this view by delving into the complexities of animal cognition. This paper aims to explore the contemporary philosophical discourse surrounding animal minds, focusing on the notion of reason rather than consciousness.

Descartes and the Post-Cartesian Legacy

Descartes’ dualistic view of mind and body set the stage for centuries of debate regarding the cognitive capacities of non-human animals. His assertion that animals lack reason due to their inability to engage in rational thought has been a foundational argument in the philosophy of mind. However, in the modern era, this Cartesian legacy has been challenged by a growing body of literature that seeks to redefine reason in a way that includes non-human animals.

The Contemporary Debate on Animal Cognition

Contemporary philosophical literature on animal cognition offers a nuanced perspective on the nature of reason in non-human animals. Rather than dismissing animals as devoid of reason, scholars today are exploring the intricate ways in which animals exhibit cognitive abilities that may be indicative of reasoning. Concepts such as concept use and causal reasoning have become central to this debate, challenging traditional notions of what it means to be a rational agent.

Rethinking Reason: Beyond Language

One key aspect of reevaluating animal minds is to move beyond a narrow definition of reason that is tied solely to language use. While language undoubtedly plays a significant role in human reasoning, it is not the sole indicator of cognitive abilities. By drawing on insights from ethology and animal cognition research, we can begin to construct a more inclusive understanding of reason that encompasses a wider range of cognitive processes.

Challenging the Status Quo: Animal Intelligence and Reasoning

Prominent figures like David Hume have argued for the presence of causal reasoning in animals, challenging the Cartesian view of non-human cognition. By examining works such as those by Frans de Waal on animal intelligence, we can glean valuable insights into the sophisticated cognitive abilities displayed by various species. These insights provide compelling support for an expanded view of reasoning that is not limited to linguistic capacities.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the debate surrounding animal minds and their capacity for reason is far from settled. By delving into contemporary philosophical literature and engaging with insights from ethology and cognitive science, we can begin to construct a more nuanced understanding of non-human cognition. Rather than clinging to outdated Cartesian notions of reason, we must embrace a broader perspective that acknowledges the diverse ways in which animals exhibit cognitive prowess. In doing so, we open up new avenues for exploring the rich tapestry of animal minds and their remarkable intellectual capabilities.

 

 

 

 

This question has been answered.

Get Answer
PLACE AN ORDER NOW

Compute Cost of Paper

Subject:
Type:
Pages/Words:
Single spaced
approx 275 words per page
Urgency:
Level:
Currency:
Total Cost:

Our Services

image

  • Research Paper Writing
  • Essay Writing
  • Dissertation Writing
  • Thesis Writing

Why Choose Us

image

  • Money Return guarantee
  • Guaranteed Privacy
  • Written by Professionals
  • Paper Written from Scratch
  • Timely Deliveries
  • Free Amendments