Evaluating Security Breach Using the AICPA’s Common Criteria
Introduction
The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) has developed a set of criteria known as the Common Criteria, which consists of nine categories for evaluating the Security Trust Service Criteria. These criteria are designed to assess the effectiveness of an organization’s security measures and controls. In this essay, we will review the attached material on the Common Criteria and utilize it to perform a quick evaluation of a selected security breach.
Thesis Statement
By utilizing the AICPA’s Common Criteria, we can evaluate the effectiveness of security measures and controls employed by an organization and identify areas of vulnerability that may have contributed to a security breach.
The AICPA’s Common Criteria
The AICPA’s Common Criteria provides a comprehensive framework for evaluating the security of an organization’s systems and processes. These criteria consist of nine categories that cover different aspects of security:
Control Environment: This category evaluates the overall security culture within the organization, including management’s commitment to security, the establishment of policies and procedures, and the presence of a qualified security team.
Communication and Information: It assesses how information is protected during transit, including encryption and secure communication protocols.
Risk Assessment: This category focuses on the identification and mitigation of potential risks, including the assessment of vulnerabilities, likelihood of exploitation, and potential impact.
Monitoring: It evaluates the organization’s ability to monitor its systems and detect any unauthorized activities or breaches in real-time.
Logical Access: This category assesses the controls in place to ensure only authorized individuals have access to systems and data, including user authentication, authorization protocols, and password management.
System Operations: It evaluates the processes and controls employed during system operations, including system backups, change management procedures, and incident response protocols.
Physical Access: This category focuses on physical security measures, such as access controls, surveillance, and environmental safeguards, to prevent unauthorized access to sensitive areas.
System Development: It assesses the security controls implemented during the development and deployment of systems, including secure coding practices, vulnerability testing, and change management protocols.
Vendor Risk Management: This category evaluates the organization’s approach to managing and mitigating security risks associated with third-party vendors and service providers.
Evaluating a Security Breach
To perform a quick evaluation of a selected security breach using the AICPA’s Common Criteria, we can analyze the breach based on each category:
Control Environment: Was there a lack of commitment to security from management? Were policies and procedures in place but not properly followed?
Communication and Information: Were there vulnerabilities in information transmission? Was encryption not utilized?
Risk Assessment: Were potential risks identified but not adequately mitigated? Was there a lack of awareness of vulnerabilities?
Monitoring: Was there a failure to detect unauthorized activities or breaches promptly? Were real-time monitoring systems lacking?
Logical Access: Was there poor user authentication or authorization controls? Were password management practices weak?
System Operations: Were system backups not performed regularly? Was there a lack of change management procedures or incident response protocols?
Physical Access: Were there inadequate physical security measures? Was unauthorized access allowed due to weak access controls?
System Development: Were secure coding practices not followed? Were proper vulnerability testing and change management protocols ignored?
Vendor Risk Management: Was there a failure to assess and mitigate risks associated with third-party vendors or service providers?
By analyzing the selected security breach against these categories, we can identify areas where the organization may have had vulnerabilities or weaknesses in its security measures and controls.
Conclusion
The AICPA’s Common Criteria provide a comprehensive framework for evaluating an organization’s security measures and controls. By utilizing these criteria, we can perform a quick evaluation of a selected security breach and identify areas where vulnerabilities or weaknesses may have contributed to the breach. This evaluation serves as a valuable tool in understanding how breaches occur and enables organizations to strengthen their security practices to prevent future incidents.
Our orders are delivered strictly on time without delay 
